rayonsports.com

The Dallas Cowboys versus the New York Giants. A classic NFC East matchup that will be renewed this weekend on the NFL schedule. This week for our Throwback Thursday feature, we’ll go back almost exactly 10 years, to a prime time Sunday night battle played on November 23, 2014, between these 2 clubs. They entered the contest at opposite ends of the spectrum, the Cowboys at 7-3 for the year and the Giants at 3-7. It turned out to be a tale of 2 halves, as the Giants took control of the game early while Dallas rallied in the second half to assume command. Giants’ quarterback Eli Manning, a Hall of Fame candidate for 2025, got his team on the board with a drive that ended in a short 3 yard touchdown pass to his rookie wide receiver Odell Beckham Jr., who was on his way to being named the Offensive Rookie Of The Year. The Cowboys countered with a Dan Bailey field goal that would turn out to be the difference in the game. It was Manning to OBJ again to start the second quarter, on a 43 yard TD throw, and the Giants now led 14-3. The half continued with the teams trading scores, Dallas cutting the lead to 14-10 when Tony Romo hit his tight end Jason Witten with a 4 yard touchdown toss and New York getting a 3 yard TD run from Andre Williams.

Romo came out with guns blazing in the second half and quickly engineered his club into the lead at 24-21 with a pair of scoring throws, 45 yards to reliable target Cole Beasley and 31 yards to Dez Bryant. Manning’s short touchdown pass to Adrien Robinson got the Giants the lead back in the fourth quarter, but Romo finished off the scoring by hitting Bryant for a 13 yard score, giving Dallas a 31-28 victory. Running back DeMarco Murray was an unsung hero for the Cowboys as he contributed a solid running game with 121 yards on 24 carries to complement Romo’s 4 touchdown passes. Despite the loss, New York gained the national spotlight with the play of the game, an amazing one-handed touchdown catch by Beckham Jr. that some pundits called the greatest catch of all time. Indeed it was what old time sportswriters would’ve called a “circus” catch. Today’s receivers, somewhat aided by modern gloves, seem to make these types of grabs routinely, but OBJ was definitely the pioneer at it. He has maintained a career in the league, with it’s share of ups and downs, and is still active today with the Miami Dolphins.

Odell Beckham Jr.’s “circus” catch

Two NFL rivals who have battled each other over the decades, the Pittsburgh Steelers and Cleveland Browns, face off on the week 12 schedule, and our featured Throwback Thursday contest, played between these clubs on September 10, 1989, was an anomaly as far as the way most games went when these AFC rivals met. It was opening day of the ’89 season and Pittsburgh’s Three Rivers Stadium was rocking, expecting coach Chuck Noll’s forces to start the year with a big win over the Browns. The game marked the head coaching debut for Cleveland of Noll’s former defensive coordinator, Bud Carson, who had been part of 2 Steeler Super Bowl wins under Noll in the 1970s.

One thing about this late ’80s version of the Steelers – they were not the Mean Joe Greene Steel Curtain, Terry Bradshaw-led club of the previous decade. The quarterback to begin this season was one Bubby Brister, who would never be mistaken for the Blonde Bomber. The Browns’ defense feasted on Pittsburgh miscues all day long. They began the game jumping out to a 17-0 first quarter lead, with a Matt Bahr field goal sandwiched between 2 defensive touchdowns scored on fumble returns by linebackers Clay Matthews and David Grayson. The onslaught continued in the second quarter as Bahr added a pair of field goals and Tim Manoa scored on a 3 yard TD run, giving Cleveland a commanding 30-0 lead at the break.

There was no letup in the second half, either. Manoa scored again on a short run, Grayson scored his second defensive touchdown of the day with a 14 yard interception return, and Mike Oliphant rambled 21 yards for the final tally. When the dust settled, the Browns had garnered a shocking 51-0 victory. The statistics didn’t lie as far as how one-sided the contest was. The Steelers turned the ball over 8 times. Brister threw 3 interceptions and was sacked 6 times. First round draft pick Tim Worley contributed 3 fumbles in his rookie debut. In all the Pittsburgh offense could only muster 53 total yards, while the Browns gained 357. No single Cleveland player collected big numbers on the day, but there were plenty of contributors, as the Browns also possessed the ball for almost 41 of the game’s 60 minutes. That’s pretty easy to do when your opponent hands you the ball 8 extra times in a game. The game was not only the worst loss in Noll’s tenure, but at that point was the worst defeat in the franchise’s 57 year history, which is saying a lot since the team didn’t have much success until Noll arrived in the ’70s.

Pittsburgh head coach Chuck Noll

It was perhaps the most important game in pro football history – Super Bowl III in Miami between the AFL’s New York Jets and NFL powerhouse Baltimore Colts, and with those 2 clubs meeting on this week’s schedule, it is an obvious pick to be chosen as this week’s throwback feature. I have featured this game in other posts regarding past Super Bowls, usually during the week of the ultimate title game, but to my actual surprise, have never given it the TBT treatment. The story of this game is pro football legend today, and the reason is because of a brash young quarterback who stood the sport on it’s collective ear.

To set up the story, let’s look at the games that got the 2 teams to this contest. The Colts were an NFL behemoth in the ’68 season. They had run roughshod through the league and finished 13-1, including running off 8 consecutive wins to finish the regular season after their lone loss, 30-20, to the Cleveland Browns. After dispatching Minnesota in the divisional playoff, they found themselves facing the Browns again in the title game.  This time, they dismantled Cleveland 34-0 and after the result of the AFL championship was decided, sportswriters and analysts everywhere predicted that the “Super Bowl” would be a laugher. In that AFL game, the underdog New York Jets, guided by the passing of their stellar quarterback Joe Namath, rallied in the final quarter to upset the previous year’s champs, the Oakland Raiders, 27-23. Oakland had beaten the Jets 43-32 earlier that year in the infamous “Heidi” game and were favored for a repeat trip to the Super Bowl.

So after 2 resounding victories for Vince Lombardi’s Packers, the third big game was expected to be even more of a one-sided rout, since it was a match between an NFL juggernaut and a club that wasn’t even seen as the best the AFL had to offer. This was reflected in the pre-game betting odds, with the Colts being installed as anywhere from 18 to 23 point favorites. Sportswriters and pundits spent the week ridiculing the Jets, and finally Namath, fed up with it all, stopped the sports world in it’s tracks when he boldly stated “We’re a better team than Baltimore. We’re going to win the game. I guarantee it.” Of course this set off a media feeding frenzy and the ridicule got even louder and more boisterous. Namath in particular, who at the time was disliked by the buttoned-up, conservative media for his unconventional look, (his white shoes, wearing a mink coat on the sidelines while injured, etc.) and his supposed wild lifestyle, took the brunt of the jokes and insults.

Then there was the actual game. Namath wasn’t particularly great, but he engineered a surgical attack mixing the run and the pass to befuddle the Baltimore defense. Running back Matt Snell, who was the unsung hero for the Jets, continually exposed a weakness on the Colts’ left side and scored the game’s first touchdown on a 4 yard run, and did yeoman’s work for the game with 121 yards on 30 carries. Namath used his  quick release to frustrate coach Don Shula’s Baltimore defense, connecting on short and intermediate throws to his backs and to wide receiver George Sauer, who caught 8 passes for 133 yards. Namath’s favorite target, future Hall of Famer Don Maynard, did not catch a pass on the day, but Namath shrewdly used the rest of his team’s weapons to lead 3 field goal drives and build up a 16-0 lead. The Jets’ defense surprisingly shut down Colts’ MVP quarterback Earl Morrall, intercepting him 3 times, including 1 by former Colt Johnny Sample, and holding him to 6 of 17 passing for a paltry 71 yards. Shula, in a sign of desperation,  eventually benched Morrall and turned to legendary John Unitas, his aging and now often injured backup. Unitas led one scoring drive but couldn’t complete the comeback, also throwing a pick.

Matt Snell, Super Bowl III’s unsung hero

When the final gun sounded, the Jets had themselves a stunning 16-7 conquest of their personal Goliath. The win sent feelings of pride throughout the other organizations in the AFL, as their league had finally shown that they were indeed an equal force to their established big brother. The next year, in the final Super Bowl played before the 2 leagues were officially merged into one, the Kansas City Chiefs, humiliated by Lombardi’s Packers in the initial title game, defeated a favored Minnesota Viking squad to end any argument that the AFL had reached parity. Incidentally, Lombardi, the smartest man in pro football at the time, was in the stands at Super Bowl III. Beforehand, he issued a warning to the Colts about Namath, saying the Colts had better not get caught up in the press clippings and underestimate him as he was “a perfect passer”.

Super Bowl III – Namath’s shining hour

It’s already week 10 of the NFL season, and on this week’s slate of games there is a matchup of a pair of old American Football League rivals, the Kansas City Chiefs and Denver Broncos. Our Throwback Thursday time machine will travel back to October 29, 1967 for this week’s TBT feature, when these Western Division clubs clashed. The Chiefs were defending AFL champions, having beaten Buffalo in the 1966 title game to advance to the initial AFL-NFL Championship game. Maybe the pounding they took from Green Bay in that game affected their psyche, or maybe it was the first case ever of “Super Bowl hangover”, but after starting the ’67 season with a pair of victories, the Chiefs had now suddenly lost 3 of 4 contests to fall to 3-3 for the year.

Facing a downtrodden Denver team coming into the game with a 1-6 record, this was a perfect opportunity for the Chiefs to right the ship and get their season back on track. They wasted little time in doing that. Fullback Curtis McClinton scored on a 1 yard plunge and Len Dawson hit tight end Fred Arbanas with a 14 yard touchdown pass to end the first quarter with his club ahead 14-0. In the second quarter, Dawson found his favorite target, Otis Taylor, on a 30 yard TD throw, then coach Hank Stram unleashed his slippery little back, Mike Garrett, who proceeded to gash the Bronco defense for touchdown runs of 20 and 8 yards. The rout was on as the score was now 35-0, but Denver stemmed the tide with a Steve Tensi to Al Denson scoring bomb of 48 yards to make it 35-7. Dawson matched that before the half with a 5 yard TD toss to Gene Thomas to up the lead to 42-7.

In the third quarter, the Broncos showed some fight, slowing down the K.C. attack and providing the only scoring of the period when they tackled Johnny Robinson in the end zone for a safety after he had intercepted a Tensi pass and tried to run with it. The final quarter went the Chiefs’ way again, as they added a Jan Stenerud field goal and a 15 yard touchdown run by backup halfback Bert Coan, putting the final touches on a 52-9 romp. Statistically, Garrett enjoyed a fine day with 20 carries for 101 yards and the 2 TDs, along with 37 receiving yards. Denson was a bright spot for Denver with 4 catches for 107 and his team’s lone touchdown. The win turned the Chiefs’ fortunes back in the right direction, and they went on to finish 9-5 for the year. However, despite being defending champs, it wasn’t good enough to qualify for the playoffs (there were no wild cards in that era) as the Oakland Raiders dominated the AFL Western Division with a stellar 13-1 record. Denver finished in it’s familiar spot – in the Western Division cellar – with a 3-11 record.

Chiefs’ back Mike Garrett

There is a matchup of the Chicago Bears and Arizona Cardinals on this week’s NFL schedule, and our Throwback Thursday time machine will take us back to November 29, 1959 for a game between these 2 old franchises. The Bears were an NFL powerhouse in the 1940s but despite declining on the field in the ’50s, they were still the favorites of fans of the city. At the time the Cardinals were also based in the Windy City, but played second fiddle to the Bears to the point that team owners decided to move to St. Louis for the 1960 season. This game is significant because it was the last home game the Cardinals would play in Chicago. Coach George Halas’ Monsters of The Midway would give their cross-town neighbors a rude sendoff, winning 31-7 in a game that was decided early.

The Bears’ played their home games in that era at Wrigley Field, the venerable old ballpark that is still home to baseball’s Cubs to this day. This matchup took place at the Cardinals’ home base of Soldier Field, for the last time of course with the move to St. Louis pending. The attendance was a bit over 48,000, but with the indifference of Cardinal fans at that point, the betting here is it was mostly a Bears’ fan crowd. The Bears’ Ed Brown had what was a typical outing at that time for a quarterback. He completed only 12 of 27 passes for a meager 188 yards, a 44% completion percentage that would be unacceptable to today’s efficiency driven signal callers, and a surprisingly below average performance in what was a one-sided game. Brown made his completions matter, however. He threw touchdown passes of 76 and 12 yards to Willard Dewveall in the first half, and John Aveni’s 24 yard field goal put Halas’ forces up 17-0 at the break. Dewveall was the statistical star of the game with 3 catches for 105 yards and the 2 TD.

Rick Casares’ 28 yard touchdown rumble put the lead at an insurmountable 24-0 in the third quarter, but the Cardinals managed one final score in their soon to be abandoned home stadium as QB King Hill tossed a 25 yard TD pass to Perry Richards. Hill had an even more miserable passing day than Brown. He was 7 of 21 (33%) for only 102 yards while being intercepted twice. Merrill Douglas’ 2 yard scoring run gave the Bears their final 31-7 advantage, and the Cardinals’ stay in Chicago, which had begun in 1920 as one of the original NFL franchises (and as an independent athletic team since 1898) came to an end. The Bidwell family, Cardinal owners, kept the club in the Gateway city until 1987, then after a stadium dispute moved them again to their current home in Arizona.

Cardinals/Bears program from 11/29/1959

On November 10, 1963 the Dallas Cowboys and San Francisco 49ers hooked up in a contest at San Francisco’s Kezar Stadium. With the Cowboys and Niners matched up on this week’s NFL schedule, that’s the game we’ll highlight for this week’s Throwback Thursday post. Both clubs were in the midst of dismal losing seasons as they entered this week 9 game, with Dallas owning only 2 wins and San Fran only a single one, having gotten their coach fired earlier in the year and now being led by interim coach Jack Christiansen.  Cowboy coach Tom Landry was in his fourth year at the helm, and would eventually build the franchise into a consistent winner, but they hadn’t quite reached “America’s Team” level yet. In fact, they regressed from where they had finished in 1962. A few weeks prior to this game, Landry made a decision that in upcoming seasons would turn the team’s fortunes around. He scrapped his quarterback shuffle plan between Eddie LeBaron and Don Meredith and installed Meredith as full time starter.

San Francisco, meanwhile, had lost starting quarterback John Brodie to a season-ending injury in October, and were being led by veteran journeyman Lamar McHan. The 2 signal callers matched each other in the first half. Meredith sandwiched touchdown passes of 15 and 24 yards to the Cowboys’ best receiver, Frank Clarke, around a 27 yard McHan to Don Lisbon scoring toss. Meredith continued his hot first half, throwing his third TD pass to Billy Howton from 15 yards out. 49er kicker Tommy Davis cut Dallas’ lead to 21-10 at halftime with a late field goal. It was McHan’s turn to shine in the second half. He led a pair of third quarter touchdown drives, ending in a 1 yard plunge by J.D. Smith and a second scoring pass to his running back Lisbon from 46 yards out. The Niners now found themselves with a 24-21 lead. McHan completed the comeback with a 20 yard scoring strike to future actor Bernie Casey, while Dallas could only muster a late field goal and wound up on the short end of a 31-24 final score.

Bernie Casey, Gargoyle and Nerd mentor

Despite the loss, Meredith had an amazing day. He completed 30 of 48 passes for 460 yards and 3 TDs (in the NFL’s 3 yards and a cloud of dust era), while 3 of his receivers, Clarke, Howton and Lee Folkins, each amassed over 100 yards. Despite 1963 being a disappointing year, making Meredith the full time starter paid dividends for coach Landry in upcoming years. The Cowboys became consistent winners and Meredith led them to the NFL title game twice, where they lost heartbreakers to Green Bay. Landry ran into the same problem in the early 1970s when he platooned Craig Morton and Roger Staubach as his QBs, only to finally reach the pinnacle of the sport with 2 Super Bowl wins going with Staubach full time.

Meredith pitches out

A pair of old NFL and NFC East opponents, the New York Giants and Philadelphia Eagles, square off on the league’s week 7 schedule, and we’ll harken back to a game played between these 2 rivals on November 26, 1972, at Yankee Stadium. It was a clash of 2 clubs at opposite ends of the spectrum. Philly had managed only 2 wins and a tie through 10 weeks of the season, while the Giants, at 6-4, were chasing both Washington and Dallas in the NFC East race. Eagle coach Ed Khayat had taken the reins early in the 1971 season after Jerry Williams was fired and the team won 6 games to finish that year, earning Khayat the full time position for ’72. Unfortunately the success didn’t carry over and Khayat was fired after the season ended.

New York had traded quarterback Fran Tarkenton back to the Minnesota Vikings prior to the ’72 season and their current field general was former Eagle Norm Snead. Snead directed a well-balanced attack in this contest that saw the Giants rack up 503 total yards, 246 on the ground and 257 through the air, in a blowout 62-10 win that was the largest margin of victory in team history. In the first quarter Snead threw a 15 yard touchdown pass to Bob Tucker and Ron Johnson rumbled 35 yards for a score to put New York up 14-0. The Eagles could only muster a Tom Dempsey field goal, and Snead continued his aerial attack in the second stanza with scoring throws of 5 yards to Joe Orduna and 29 yards to Tucker. Pete Gogolak added a 25 yard field goal in between the touchdowns and the Giants were now comfortably in front 31-3. The Eagles struck lightning when their QB, John Reaves, found Harold Jackson for a 77 yard score. Snead countered that before the half ended with a drive ending in a 1 yard TD plunge by Johnson, putting New York ahead 38-10.

Giants’ coach Alex Webster called off the dogs somewhat in the second half when he replaced Snead with backup Randy Johnson, but it didn’t make much difference. Gogolak added a field goal and the second string signal caller fired a pair of touchdown passes, of 32 and 63 yards, to Don Hermann against the hapless Eagle defense, then wrapped up the scoring himself with a 1 yard YD run to account for the final 62-10 score. Statistically, the 2 New York quarterbacks combined for 5 touchdown passes, Tucker had 8 receptions for 100 yards and Hermann 2 catches for 95 with both scoring a pair of touchdowns. Ron Johnson carried 22 times for 123 yards and also scored twice. The lone bright spot for the Eagles was Harold Jackson with 5 catches for 152 yards and his long touchdown. The Giants fell short of making the playoffs, losing 2 of their final 3 games, while Philly never won another and finished in the NFC East basement.

Giants-Eagles highlights from 11/26/72

On December 6, 1987, a game was played between 2 clubs who meet on this week’s NFL schedule – the New Orleans Saints and Tampa Bay Buccaneers. That game will be our feature for this week’s Throwback Thursday. Coach Jim Mora’s Saints, at 8-3, were fighting for a playoff spot while the Bucs were languishing in a losing season. New Orleans looked to take the fight out of their opponent as quarterback Bobby Hebert and tight end John Tice hooked up on a pair of short touchdown passes in the first quarter to jump out to a 14-0 lead. Bucs’ QB Vinny Testaverde worked his way into the end zone from a yard out to give Tampa their first score. New Orleans, obviously proving to be the better team, started the second quarter the same as they did the first. This time their running game finished drives, as Rueben Mayes scored on a 7 yard run and Dalton Hilliard pranced in from 3 yards out. The Bucs managed a field goal before the half to cut the Saints’ lead to 28-10, but the game appeared to be all but over when New Orleans added 2 more scores – a 40 yard Morten Andersen field goal and a 2 yard Mayes rushing TD, to move ahead 38-10.

Tampa Bay was not about to roll over and play dead yet, however. Testaverde found Mark Carrier for a 37 yard touchdown pass, and Donald Igwebuike booted a 43 yard field goal to cut the deficit to 38-20 after 3 quarters. Andersen stemmed the tide with another field goal but Testaverde went back to work and tossed a 12 yard touchdown pass to Bruce Hill. Now leading 41-27, Andersen finished the Saints’ scoring with another three pointer. Still not finished battling, the Bucs drove to another touchdown behind Testaverde, this one completed by a 2 yard Bobby Howard run. A loss is a loss, and the defeat lowered Tampa’s season record to 4-8, but the team’s effort to shorten the final score to 44-34 was valiant. Testaverde wound up throwing for 369 yards, while Carrier had a career day with 8 receptions for 212 yards and his TD.  This Saints’ victory officially qualified them for the playoffs for the first time in franchise history, but they wound up being blown out 44-10 in the wild card round by Minnesota.

Coach Jim Mora, architect of the Saints’ first playoff team

The Buffalo Bills travel to Houston this Sunday to take on the Texans, and this week’s Throwback Thursday feature is from a game played between these 2 teams just a few years ago, on January 4, 2020. It was an AFC Wild Card game set at Houston’s NRG Stadium, with the Texans being AFC South champions, while Buffalo qualified for the playoffs with a second place finish in the AFC East. Buffalo used some trickery to open the scoring in the first quarter, as offensive coordinator Brian Daboll dialed up a play that saw wide receiver John Brown hit quarterback Josh Allen with a throwback pass that resulted in a 16 yard touchdown.

Josh Allen scores on trick play option pass

The Bills’ defense put the locks on the Texans for the entire first half, holding them scoreless. Meanwhile Steven Hauschka contributed a pair of 40 yard field goals to give his club a 13-0 halftime lead. When Hauschka hit his third consecutive three-pointer in the third quarter, it upped the Bills’ lead to 16-0 and set up a play on the ensuing kickoff that changed the momentum of the game. The kickoff went into the end zone and was fielded by Houston’s DeAndre Carter, who then flipped the ball at the feet of an official. The ref never blew his whistle, and the Bills alertly rushed in and recovered the ball for an apparent touchdown, since the returner never really downed the ball by taking a knee. It would have given Buffalo pretty much an insurmountable lead, but then the inexplicable happened. A mysterious black-clad “common sense” alternate official came in from the sideline and overruled the refs on the field, negating the score by ruling that the Texans’ player’s “intention” was to down the ball when he flipped it in the vicinity of the official standing next to him. These extra refs, only used during the playoffs to keep the guys who didn’t earn playoff games because of poor performance during the regular season employed, somehow were given the authority over the actual game officials.

Being let off the hook must have given the Texans a jolt of energy, because they stormed back to score 19 unanswered points to go ahead 19-16 in the fourth quarter. Quarterback DeShaun Watson ran 20 yards for a score and then added a 2 point conversion run, Kai Fairbairn kicked a field goal and Watson hit Carlos Hyde with a short scoring pass, and added another 2 point conversion with a toss to DeAndre Hopkins. Buffalo battled back to tie the game with another Hauschka field goal, sending the contest into overtime. They were burned in the extra period by an old friend and former teammate, Taiwan Jones, who grabbed a short Watson pass and rambled 34 yards to set up a winning 28 yard field goal by Fairbairn, giving the Texans a 22-19 win.

Mysterious “alternate” ref affecting the game’s outcome

The Miami Dolphins and Tennessee Titans clash on the week 4 NFL schedule, and for this week’s Throwback Thursday post we will feature a game played between these 2 franchises in the Dolphins’ inaugural expansion season of 1966. The Titans were the Houston Oilers at that time, and although they won the first 2 American Football League championships, they were on a steep decline when this game was played on December 18, 1966. Miami had managed 2 wins so far in their first year, and 1 of them was earlier in Houston over the Oilers at Rice Stadium. Houston came into this matchup, the final regular season game for both clubs, with only 3 wins. Needless to say, in spite of being at the end of a lost year, they did not want to suffer the embarrassment of being defeated twice in a season by an expansion team.

Houston quarterback Don Trull found running back Hoyle Granger for a 27 yard touchdown pass to get the scoring started in the first quarter, and then hooked up with Larry Elkins in the second from 11 yards out to give his Oilers a 14-0 lead. Miami signal caller John Stofa then began what would become a career day by hitting Joe Auer with a 27 yard scoring toss. The Dolphins added a 2 point conversion (which was only a rule in the AFL, not the NFL, back then). Trull was unfazed, and upped the Oiler lead to 21-8 with a 2 yard TD pass to Bob McLeod. Stofa was the man in the second half. He provided the only score of the third quarter with a 48 yard bomb to flanker Frank Jackson. Trull’s 1 yard QB sneak gave Houston a 28-15 advantage, but Stofa capped his performance with a pair of touchdown drives that ended with his third and fourth TD throws – 4 yards to Bill Cronin and 14 to Auer. Gene Mingo’s successful extra point kicks on those 2 scores put Miami up 29-28 and they hung on to hand the Oilers another loss. Auer had 87 rushing yards in addition to his 2 receiving TDs, while Jackson amassed 110 receiving yards on 4 catches from Stofa.

Two years later Stofa would be traded to Cincinnati prior to their expansion draft to enter the AFL in ’68, officially becoming the first Bengal player in team history, only to return to the Dolphins for the ’69 and ’70 seasons.

John Stofa, Pride of University of Buffalo