From left: Andre Reed, Chris Carter, Tim Brown.
Wide receiver may be the position that causes the most controversy when it comes to debates over who belongs in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. There have been so many great ones over the years that it is hard to sort out which ones belong, and it seems even the ones who do belong always wind up waiting to get there. The case of Art Monk, who is finally in after years of waiting, is an example of this. So this listing of best receivers who aren’t in Canton is divided up into 2 sections. First, there are 3 slam dunk candidates who aren’t in, but it’s just a matter of time before they are. They are the 3 pictured above – Andre Reed, who had a dynamic career with the Buffalo Bills, Chris Carter, who played in Philadelphia and mostly Minnesota and, as his old Eagles coach Buddy Ryan said when justifying trading him, “All he did was catch touchdowns”. The third is former Raider Tim Brown. None of these 3 need arguments to warrant their place in the Hall. Their careers are their arguments.
From left: Cliff Branch, Harold Carmichael, Drew Pearson.
So it’s on to the rest of the list, starting with former Eagle Harold Carmichael. He played 14 seasons in the NFL, was a 4 time Pro Bowler and was voted to the NFL’s all-decade team for the 1970s, which should be an automatic ticket to induction. Drew Pearson of the Dallas Cowboys, the favorite target of Roger Staubach for most of his career, is similar to Carmichael. He also was an all-decade team member for the ’70s, was a multiple year Pro Bowler and All-Pro choice and played on a Super Bowl championship team. Cliff Branch of the Raiders was overshadowed by his Hall of Fame teammates, Fred Biletnikoff and Dave Casper, when he played, but was just as important a receiver on those Raider teams as those two were. There were a lot of great receivers who played in anonimity in the old American Football League who should be considered, including Lionel Taylor of Denver, Charley Hennigan of the old Houston Oilers and Elbert “Golden Wheels” Dubenion of the Buffalo Bills. Being that it is almost impossible for players who played exclusively in the AFL to get in, these players have little hope of making it, even though they deserve the honor and are easily as good as 2 of their AFL counterparts who did get in, Lance Alworth and Don Maynard. There is one old AFL receiver who stands out above the rest and should be in Canton. That would be Otis Taylor of the Kansas City Chiefs. He played on 2 championship teams, including the Super Bowl IV champs, has deserving career stats and was also a devastating downfield blocker which helped the Chiefs’ running game succeed.
Lionel Taylor (left) and Otis Taylor.
There are a lot of honorable mention type players in the receiver category also, and those would include Del Shofner of the 1960s NY Giants, Henry Ellard, who had a brilliant 16 year NFL career and has deserving numbers, Harold Jackson, similar to Ellard in numbers (he played almost 20 years), Roy Green of the Cardinals, Gary Collins of Cleveland, who starred on teams in the 1960s that featured the running game with Jim Brown and then LeRoy Kelly (both hall of famers) and also played opposite HOFer Paul Warfield, Isaac Curtis of Cincinnati and Boyd Dowler of the 1960s Green Bay Packers. There are surely others who I am overlooking, but this is definitely the most competitive position as far as getting considered for immortality in Canton.
Gary Collins (left) and Isaac Curtis.